
So I have this dilemma thing. Over the past year or two, I've paid an increased attention to the complaints against the fairly-plain, sexist nature of comic book fiction. Things in the realm of comics (and especially in the genres of superhero fiction and many of the genres native to Japanese manga) are a bit antique. Every month, there seems to be a fresh target upon which to vent one's righteous indignation against the indignities disproportionately bestowed upon the female character. There are entire sites devoted to women's issues in comics (with most that I've seen focusing on the ins and outs of the American mainstream affairs). The main point, however, is that things are not great.
Which puts many female comic readers on edge, looking out for these breaches of egalitarian principle.

Which is where my dilemma comes in. The graphic novel on which I've been working since November features a female as the lead. I think she's a pretty good character and engaging. Strong in some areas, greatly flawed in others. Kinda like real people. Or so I intend.
The problem is that in delving into this feminist subculture of the comics subculture, I get the feeling that no matter what I write, I can't win. Along with all the good critique I've read, I've also been pretty taken aback at some of the grossly inadequate critique out there. For every feminist out there who's giving things a fair evaluation, there are those who operate on assumption rather than evidence—tarring, feathering, and dismissing with a description that becomes so common that it begins to lose all strength: misogyny.

What worries me is not the reasonable critics. It's the ones who don't need to be reasonable. One of the dangers in taking on the identity of a critic is that one tends to feel the need to find error so deeply that one is not satisfied if error is not found. I see this all the time with burgeoning young proofreaders and editors (yes, part of my skillset is that of a master editor!*). After a few weeks of proofreading and editing, they become so anxious to find mistakes that they begin seeing them everywhere. Even things that are not mistakes. When they become especially attached to their role, it often takes some fierce discussion to convince them that they are not seeing what they imagine they are seeing. I'm gathering that a portion of the feminist (note: not female) comic-blogging atmosphere is suffering from such a malady.
For every honest appraisal of sexism in comics, we're getting hit with over-reactions and presumptions. Or maybe that ratio's off. Maybe it's 3 reactions :: 1 overreaction? Or 1 reaction :: 2 overreactions? Or 10 reactions :: 3 overreactions? I don't know. What I do know is that its dangerous to put out a book in this kind of environment.

What I mean when I say "this kind of environment" is a charged environment. Feminist momentum in the realm of comics-blogging is picking up. And as that momentum picks up, the sightings of Jesus in a tortilla will be picking up as well. Things that deserve ire will garner it—but what about the innocent stuff that gets caught in the sweep?
I'm essentially the poster-child for American privilege. I'm white, male, Protestant, blond-haired, blue-eyed, not fat, and I grew up in Laguna Beach. The only count in my favour is that I didn't grow up rich (as my father was an artist—and not one of the $2500-per-work kinds either). I've got all the marks against me that screams: "How can you write a ____ character? You don't know what it's like to be me! You've never endured the struggle or prejudice that I have!" And it's true. My struggles have nothing to do with speaking English as a second language, being discriminated against because of the colour of my skin, being dismissed because I don't have a Y chromosome, or being hated/feared because my sexuality deviates from norm.

All the same, I like stories—and think I have one worth telling. One about a woman.
After having written it, I'm worried that I will be perceived as misogynistic Not by the reasonable—I have no fear of my acquittal on their part. But it's the ones looking for trouble that worry me. One of the things that makes the reception of a creative work such a dicey proposition is that I see some feminists praising a specific instance in a book while other feminists revile the same instance. And both groups cite their feminism as the basis for their decision to praise or revile.

Colour me baffled.
Really, it shouldn't surprise me, as people constantly cite ideology as the fuel for their evaluations. I knew people who voted for Bush because they were Christians and couldn't, in good conscience, vote any other way. I knew people who would not vote for Bush because they were Christians and couldn't, in good conscience, support his presidency. I know I shouldn't fear this dynamic, but ideologies are powerful (and often unpredictable) things. And this book is dear to me and I don't want to see it sacrificed to thoughtlessness.
I count myself fortunate that I'm just in the first year of a four-year project and that the climate may have been entirely mellowed and resolved by the time I'm ready to present my story. But if its the same? Or worse? How can a creator win?
I don't believe there is anything in my book that should offend readers to the point that the story is tainted. I do believe that some will be offended and the story ruined for them. I did my best to craft not just a believable woman (which would be inadequate) but to craft a believable person. Bad things happen and she doesn't come out completely rosey. I think a good feminist/humanist/what-have-you could read my story and be satisfied that I did a good job with what she's looking for. I guess the current climate just worries me is all.
*note: don't take my blog writing as evidence that I'm a bad proofer, everything on this site is first drafted and though it could use a good proofing, I'll save that for my serious writing.
Some resources discussing women in comics:
When Fangirls Attack - hand-edited aggregation of articles on women in comics
Pretty, Fizzy Paradise - posts on comics by Kalinara
The Beat - sociology-tagged posts from The Beat
Comics Worth Reading - Johanna Draper Carlson reviews comics
Written Worlds - posts on comics by Ragnell
Girls Read Comics (And They're Pissed - Karen Healy is angry
and...
Some of my own musings on related mattersLabels: comics, projects, sexism, social issues