A Comparative Review:
Neon Genesis Evangelion vs. RahXephon
About a year ago (or was it two), I got the complete series of Neon Genesis Evangelion on sale for $29.oo. It was a price I could hardly pass up. The show retails for $169.98 and usually sales at Amazon for $135.98. That combined with the fact that Evangelion stands among the most lauded television productions in Japan's animated history. It may even be The most highly regarded animated show ever. Or at least to date. It seemed a safe investment.
It wasn't.
There is nothing spectacular or even note-worthy about the show. The characterizations are weak and stalled, never developing beyond those cardboard standees you'll see in Suncoast Video accompanying the latest released features. There is only one character whose development arch is anything close to interesting - and Misato Katsuragi, though afforded a modicum of screentime, is not even one of the principles. The story moves like molassas - when it decides to move at all. The pauses in dialogue are not only pregnant, but overdue. The premise, while vaguely interesting, is drowned in a heavy-handed and out-of-place air of religious arcana - an air that I suspect makes some of its audience imagine there is more substance to the show than there really is. As an example from a top-rated Amazon review:
As an example of the many layers to the story, there is a tremendous amount of Judeo-Christian symbolism worked into the story. The Sephiroth, the Kabalah's tree of life, the Dead Sea Scrolls, the Lance of Longinus, and cruciform images abound. All of this adds up to an impending sense of apocalypse, but the truth us far stranger. Hideaki Anno has intentionally used this symbolism to create an atmosphere that is 'mysterious' to his Japanese audiences. Yet there is a whole other spiritual layer that is uniquely Japanese, drawing deeply from the Kojiki, an ancient creation legend. This is something many non-Japanese viewers will miss.
That, in case you missed it, is straightup bullcrap.
And even if one inexplicably finds the repititious and vain drama intriguing, there is no conclusion to the show. At least no sensible conclusion. The final two episodes abandon all sense of storytelling and embark on a stream-of-consciousnessdriven wrap-up that is both painful and tedious. Nothing is concluded. Nothing makes sense. Evangelion is, in the end, naught but sound and fury without significance. Nihilism is the only produce.
Not only was $29.oo not a bargain, but I feel raped. Both of my money and, far more precious, of my time. Sure I can claim to have seen the whole thing and sure I was sitting in airports and on runways for a good chunk of that time, but when you consider that I could have been watching Cheaper by the Dozen or Honey, I Blew up the Baby, you should be weeping violently for me.
Fast-forward to a month ago when I began watching RahXephon through my Netflix subscription.
I was understandably skeptical. Every review of the show I read had compared it to Neon Genesis Evangelion - and having seen them both now, it's easy to understand why.
Elementally, the two shows share a lot of similarities. Both feature a teenage male with a unique talent for piloting a biomechanical colossus. Both feature ostensibly alluring adult women as the immediate guardian of the chosen male teen. Both feature regular attacks from impossibly large and alien opponents, which require the reluctant teen to pilot his biomechanical 'thing' into combat. Both feature a male teen as The saviour of his world and its future. And both have unecessarily strange finales.
Still, through almost every moment, RahXephon succeeds where Evangelion fails miserably. It's far from perfect, but the entire time, I was thinking, "Ohhhh, this is what they meant to do when they made Evangelion." It's as if someone watched the more venerable show and just decided to fix it.
The characters are almost all engaging - even the minor ones. In an astonishing turn-around from Evangelion, you might find it possible to actually like some of RahXephon's characters. True, there are times when the principle's confusion and double-mindedness can become tiresome, but in the overall, it's easy to cut him slack. The storyline and characters actually develop along lines toward a goal - something unheard of in Evangelion. More, there are continual revelations that keep drawing the viewer back into the story before it becomes too dulling. While the tale could have been told in thirteen episodes, RahXephon justifies its twenty-six episode run gracefully.
And beautifully. The animation is crisp. The characters are drawn with care and the design, especially of the alien opponents (the dolem of the Mu race), is really just way cool. Strangely, the least inspired design of the series is in the title-character, the enormous biomechanical colossus, Xephon. Aurally, as well, the music is well-developed and plays its part, almost as its own character.
Perhaps the only real flaw is the shows final episodes, where the seemingly Japanese penchant for incomprehensible endings rears its head. Not as boggling as some endings, RahXephon's still devolves into metaphysical mumbo-jumbo and relies heavily on the viewers' abilities to suspend disbelief and accept an odd view of reality and the universe (its unnatural enough that 98% of the cast has no idea what's going on either). In the end, things are resolved, but one cannot be quite sure how. People appear to have died, but maybe they really didn't. In the end, it doesn't matter. One of the final episodes is entitled "Deus ex Machina." I suspect that would have been a better title for the final episode.
As an added bonus for those who did enjoy the series and its romantic aspect, there is a sweet scene that plays after the final credits roll. It made me smile and feel warm things - something that only burning the set could accomplish with my Neon Genesis Evangelion Perfect [sic] Collection.
In sum, to quantify:
Neon Genesis Evangelion:
RahXephon: